200 word Response 1 reference/intext citation Due 3/27/2024 Dugar Taking into consideration the information covered in the presentation and these

200 word Response 1 reference/intext citation Due 3/27/2024

Dugar

Taking into consideration the information covered in the presentation and these articles, what is your opinion of the validity of latent print identification? Additionally, how do these issues affect the validity other types of impression evidence? 

After reading through the materials provided, I conclude that the validity of latent print identification is not as sound and accurate as it has been presented. There are numerous loopholes that can lead to misidentification thus lowering the validity of the technique as a sole source of evidence. In other words, there needs to be additional pieces of evidence that align alongside the latent print identification for a conviction to be granted. While the technique of fingerprint identification has been accepted as evidence in courts for over a century, the process of latent print identification presents loopholes that can mislead the evidence. In her judgment summary for the Brian Keith Rose murder case, Judge Susan M. Souder explains how the ACE-V (Analysis, Comparison, Evaluation, Verification) process used in latent print identification is conducted (State of Maryland vs. Brian Rose 13). Reading through, there are many areas where errors could occur throughout the process. For example, in the analysis phase, bias may infiltrate the process if the examiner is considering particular known prints. In the verification phase, it is highly unlikely that the second examiner disputes the conclusion of the first examiner especially when they already know what that conclusion is, which is usually the case. That explains one of the major reasons why the misidentification of Brandon Mayfield occurred in May, 2004. Two FBI examiners and a supervisor agreed that the prints were Mayfield’s, which was not true.

The issues identified in latent print identification are likely to taint the validity of other types of impression evidence. This is because the technique used in latent print identification is similar to that used on other impression evidence such as a footprint. After the Mayfield case, the FBI Laboratory set up a committee to conduct internal review of what had caused the error. In their reporting, the FBI committee noted that “the methodology surrounding latent fingerprint examination – like most pattern disciplines – has more subjectivity than other forensic disciplines…” (Zarwell and Dutton 2022). The recommendation offered by the committee was to use black box testing, a technique that tests both the examiners and the methods used simultaneously.

Notably, the risks that exist in the process of latent print identification and other impression evidence does not rule out their potential to produce accurate information. What is required is objectivity and commitment to independence by examiners when conducting the ACE-V process. Judge Souder quotes one of the expertise in the Brian Rose as saying that “During forensic comparison, one must maintain an objective state of mind to guard against seeing things that are not there, (State of Maryland vs. Brian Rose 14). Also, the pressure that comes with solving some cases, especially the high profile ones like the Madrid train bombings can overwhelm the investigations and they develop some haste which could end up affecting accuracy and therefore thwarting justice. When done professionally, latent print identification and other impression evidence can produce accurate outcomes.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Financial management knowledge

Description The company that I want to work with and the writer can choose will be Google. The first part of the assignment should be done with 14 days. FIN 320 Module Three Excel Assignment Rubric This is the first of two Excel assignments you will complete in this course.

2 Page APA FORMAT Paper Summarizing How Politics Became Our Identity: Uncivil Agreement by Lillana Mason. DUE TOMORROW 11202020 Before

2 Page APA FORMAT Paper Summarizing How Politics Became Our Identity: Uncivil Agreement by Lillana Mason. DUE TOMORROW 11/20/2020 Before 5 PM. Chapters 4-6. Each chapter should be summarized separately and labeled. https://www.amazon.com/Uncivil-Agreement-Politics-Became-Identity/dp/022652454X^ This is the correct book. ( I have the paperback I do not have online access)

Change management papers

I.   Statement of problem area. In this section, describe the change attempt and the key players.        A. Background of change attempt.   1.  Nature of change (What is being proposed?). 2.  Issues (Why is it being proposed?). 3.  Change Agent(s). A. Personality. B. Power. C. Motive for being

      Understand the basic principles of Contract Law and the Law

      Understand the basic principles of Contract Law and the Law of Tort and apply them in business circumstances. (ULO 2)– Analyse the legal environment in which business structures operate and evaluate their use in a commercial context. (ULO 3)  – Apply correct legal methodology, specifically to apply the IRAC

For this assignment, develop a table of cases to use

  For this assignment, develop a table of cases to use as a reference in the future. Your table of cases should include 3-5 cases involving FAPE and 3-5 cases involving LRE. For each case, you must include: An appropriate legal-style citation. Here is a sample: Brown v. Board of

The title sounds quite fancy, doesn’t it? Well, in reality,

   The title sounds quite fancy, doesn’t it? Well, in reality, is kind of fancy. For all the alcohol lovers out there, especially the ones who prefer wine, this is going to be a fantastic read for them.  For people who like to enjoy drinking wine with friends, at a

75 Word reply Hello Class, the following are my thoughts

75 Word reply   Hello Class, the following are my thoughts on the criteria needed to identify the critical region and how to decide to utilize a one-tailed vs a two-tailed test. As the textbook states, the purpose behind stage two is to set the criteria for making a decision

Conduct a literature search to locate recent, peer-reviewed scholarly publications related to the cultural and religious or spiritual beliefs and practices of two culturally diverse population groups currently residing in the United States.

Cultural, Religious or Spiritual Beliefs and Practices; Implications for Compliance to Healthcare Regimens Conduct a literature search to locate recent, peer-reviewed scholarly publications related to the cultural and religious or spiritual beliefs and practices of two culturally diverse population groups currently residing in the United States. Concisely describe the key

Promotional Methods of Healthcare System

(1) Create an infographic of the major promotional methods a healthcare system should employ – Make sure to have an integrated approach. Demonstrate your understanding by apply the methods you recommend. Give examples. (2) Utilize various methods, remembering your various promotional tools (Advertising, Public Relations, Personal Selling, Sales Promotion, Digital,

History Of Presenting Complaints

Case Scenario Russell is a truck driver aged 68 years whos admitted to Monash Health with breathlessness. History Of Presenting Complaints He describes progressive dyspnoea that he has had for the past three months and is now breathless when showering and dressing. For the past week, he has felt more

Your readings this week provide a historical view of authentic

  Your readings this week provide a historical view of authentic leadership. Address the following question in the discussion board: What do you believe is the largest contributing factor to the evolution of leadership style? If you had a crystal ball, what do you believe leadership style will look like

ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS BELOW, EACH QUESTION SHOULD BE TWO

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

Wall of Silence Reflective Journal

Based upon Gibson and Singh Part 1 and 2: Breaking the Silence. Gibson and Singh provided alarming statistics based upon the IOM’s 1999 report of 100,000 deaths per year due to medical errors. According to Gibson and Singh, this translates to 275 deaths due to medical errors every day. Based

Deliverable Length: 10-15 PowerPoint slides (each slide should include 200-250

Deliverable Length:   10-15 PowerPoint slides (each slide should include 200-250 words each in the notes section) Based on your discussions with Michelle, you have developed a clear picture of the environmental issues that will affect the initial release of the new product. As you compile your notes, the phone rings.