Assignment 2: Case Study You are a clerk for the Virginia Court of Appeals. You have been tasked with reviewing

Assignment 2: Case Study
You are a clerk for the Virginia Court of Appeals. You have been tasked with reviewing the cases of Able, Baker, and Charlie. All three defendants have appealed their convictions, and your job is to review the motions for appeals and discuss the merits of the claims raised. You do not need to decide if the claims are correct, only if there is an actual issue raised that should be reviewed by the Court of Appeals. You will need to provide a review of each case and cite specific issues and evidence supporting any possible errors. The whole review should be submitted in a 6- to 8-page Microsoft Word document.
Case 1: Able
Able has been convicted of both reckless driving, under Code of Virginia § 46.2-862, and possession of controlled substances, under Code of Virginia § 18.2-250. For the purposes of this charge, methamphetamine is considered a Schedule II substance.
Able raises the following points of error in his motion for an appeal:
The search that uncovered the controlled substance violated the defendants Fourth Amendment rights as the officer had no warrant.
The methamphetamine was not identified solely by touch during a frisk (see Minnesota v. Dickerson, 1993).
The case was tried by a six-person jury though both charges were felonies.
Case 2: Baker
Baker was convicted of both assault and battery, under Code of Virginia § 18.2-57, and grand larceny, under Code of Virginia § 18.2-95. Baker raises the following points of error in his motion for an appeal:
The prosecutions expert witness, Dr. Hiknow, is not licensed as a medical doctor or a psychiatrist in the Commonwealth of Virginia. His testimony was objected to at the trial but allowed.
Witness statements by a second neighbor, attesting to the motivation of the complaining neighbor, were incorrectly excluded as hearsay.
The police searched the vehicles in Bakers yard without a warrant, violating his Fourth Amendment rights.
The evidence found in the outbuildings was incorrectly allowed as evidence as it was found following an illegal search and should have been subject to the exclusionary rule.
A challenge to one juror by Baker sattorney was not allowed. This juror was known to have strong beliefs about firearms, and the defense believed that the juror could not be impartial.
Case 3: Charlie
Charlie was convicted of both public intoxication, under Code of Virginia § 18.2-388, and murder and manslaughter, under Code of Virginia § 18.2-30.
Charlie raises the following points of error in his motion for an appeal:
The death sentence was imposed.
Three jurors were not empaneled after they admitted they could not impose the death penalty on any defendant.
The defendants statements to the police when the body was found should not have been allowed as evidence since the defendant had only been given a Miranda warning the previous day regarding the intoxication charge.
The search of the defendants car violated his Fourth Amendment rights as there was no probable cause to search the trunk.
The identification by lineup was tainted as the witness saw Charlie being brought into the jail prior to the lineup.
The statements of Charlies cellmate were improperly allowed as evidence. The defense contends that these statements were hearsay and should have been excluded. In all three cases, be sure to focus on the validity of the issue raised and not the actual outcome on any of the issues. Be sure to discuss both sides of each issue. If the issues raised could possibly have changed the outcome of the trial, they should be reviewed by the appellate court.
Note: You can use the Internet to find information about the Virginia Legislative Information System and the specific codes. Support your responses with examples. Cite any sources in APA format.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

100-200 words Must cite hyperlink to article titled “healthcare” Reply

100-200 words Must cite hyperlink to article titled “healthcare” Reply to the following: Diane Roberts 6:16 AM Hi Everyone, Welcome to Week Five. Business today especially in the healthcare setting has a lot of patients from all over the world and we need to connect with them. Technology allows hospitals

This is a two part discussion question. Part I: Identify

 This is a two part discussion question. Part I: Identify and discuss the project topic, problem and purpose thesis statements, and main points/sections with classmates. Be comprehensive and detailed.  Part II: Considering your specific research topic, “thoroughly” discuss your research efforts. In addition, relate your academic and other legitimate sources

Before starting a process improvement project, it is important to

  Before starting a process improvement project, it is important to understand Six Sigma team roles and how best to manage stakeholder relationships or engagement. Without an understanding of roles and responsibilities along with ongoing stakeholder engagement, project chaos will likely ensue. This assignment will provide an opportunity for you

  Diversity Issues in the Field of Psychology What did you learn

  Diversity Issues in the Field of Psychology What did you learn about this week that grabbed your attention or caused you to think more deeply about it? Cultural competence is defined as one’s ability to interact with people from belief systems outside of our own by way of acknowledging

Respond to each of the questions below. Think of a

  Respond to each of the questions below.  Think of a design change that you have witnessed or researched. Evaluate the pace and timing, scope and sequencing, communication, and feedback and learning in the initiative. What would you change about the transition? Choose one of the quadrants of the Competing

Using the attached Goal Writing for Replacement Behavior downloaddocument, Write

  Using the attached Goal Writing for Replacement Behavior downloaddocument, Write two replacement behavior goals that align with your first discussion goals for increasing positive behaviors. Write two replacement behavior goals that align with your first discussion goals for decreasing problem behaviors. Next, in a paragraph, Identify the disability you are

Hello, i need this paper by 2/03 afternoon. Strictly No plagiarism please

Hello, i need this paper by 2/03 afternoon. Strictly No plagiarism please use your own words.Discuss in 500 words your opinion whether Edward Snowden is a hero or a criminal. You might consider the First Amendment and/or the public’s right to know as well as national security concerns.  Use at least

Imagine that you are the human resources (HR) manager at

Imagine that you are the human resources (HR) manager at a manufacturing company. The company you work for is trying to determine whether it can make the switch from using a merit-based pay plan to an incentive-based pay plan. As the HR manager, it is your responsibility to explain each pay plan

Leitner, K. (2008, August 16). Top Tips: Cultural diversity in

 Leitner, K. (2008, August 16). Top Tips: Cultural diversity in businesses. The New Zealand Herald.  Lubin, G. (2015, January 20). These 8 scales reveal everything you should know about different cultures. Business Insider What characteristics do culturally competent communicators exhibit? Why would culturally competent communicators be an asset in a

1. Qualitative data has been described as voluminous and sometimes overwhelming to the researcher. Discuss two strategies that would help

1. Qualitative data has been described as voluminous and sometimes overwhelming to the researcher. Discuss two strategies that would help a researcher manage and organize the data. 2 references(will be provided to you).2.The three types of qualitative research are phenomenological, grounded theory, and ethnographic research. Compare the differences and similarities

Individuals can experience trauma from public events at the national

Individuals can experience trauma from public events at the national level or extremely private ones at the interpersonal level. In this Discussion, you analyze these two types of trauma, describing potential interventions and their effectiveness. To prepare: Read the DSM-5 section on trauma and stressor-related disorders and review the Learning

Thank you for sharing Raising awareness about HIV. Do you

  Thank you for sharing  Raising awareness about HIV. Do you know if Florida’s legislation is currently working on this initiative? I often scan through what is going on in the state of New Hampshire and look at the list of Bills. Sometimes I find some of what is on the

  Write a 750-1,000-word essay that develops a 4-week Problem-Solving Treatment

  Write a 750-1,000-word essay that develops a 4-week Problem-Solving Treatment (PST) approach to help a student struggling with ADHD or weight loss management. Use the seven-step strategy below: Define the problem Choose a realistic goal Identify three strategies to reach the goal Evaluate the feasibility of each strategy Choose

Download data on a company’s stock history. From this data,

Download data on a company’s stock history. From this data, create scatterplots, histograms, and calculate the mean, median, mode, and standard deviation of some data points. Write a 5-8 page report including the graphs and descriptive statistics you have created. Business analytics techniques are used to facilitate decision making by